Acknowledged by: City of Ann Arbor

Signal repair Acknowledged

Barton Dr & Pontiac Trl Ann Arbor, MI, 48105, USA Show on Map Hide Map
Move the marker to represent your issue's location. The address will not change.

Reporter

Issue ID:

9507820

Submitted To:

City of Ann Arbor

Category:

Signal repair

Viewed:

105 times

Neighborhood:

Ann Arbor

Reported:

on

Service Request ID:

394758

Description

In December of 2019, I submitted a fixit request. Here's the text: "I suspect the video detection system used in this traffic light is not properly calibrated. There is a known problem with video detection systems that they mis-identify bicyclists as distant motor vehicles. When this is the case, and what I've seen from this system, the system will give a green light to most motorists approaching on a leg that's already green, but quickly change to red on the approach of a cyclist. But they do detect the cyclist, as the trigger for the next green phase will reliably be set for a cyclist. I've found in general for this light, unless there are motor vehicles already nearby in my direction, this signal will usually turn to red for me (unless I am traveling over 20mph) approaching on my bike even if there is no cross traffic within detection range, and there has been none since the last signal change.

Supposedly, the software in these units has a configurable pixel size for detection, that can correct this problem. Someone should verify with the manufacturer of this system what the current pixel detect size is set to, and what it should be set to in situations with significant bicycle traffic, for the signal to operate properly."

The city explained that it's a radar system, did nothing to fix the problem, and closed the request. So, the problem is the radar system has a problem detecting bicycles properly; improperly resulting in red lights for bicyclists pretty much every time, even when there is no other traffic around. That's defective, please fix that. This issue won't be resolved until the signal doesn't discriminate against bicyclists. Your solution should involve a change that doesn't result in bicyclists getting red lights when a motorist wouldn't.


Post a New Comment

1 Comment

  • Acknowledged City of Ann Arbor (Verified Official)

New Comment

Public status changes are not available for this issue.